Ñòàòüÿ 'Ñðåäíå- è ïîçäíåãîëîöåíîâûå îïîëçíè íà ñåâåðíîì ñêëîíå õðåáòà Àèáãà' - æóðíàë 'Àðêòèêà è Àíòàðêòèêà' - NotaBene.ru
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Peer-review process > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy > Editorial Board > Council of Editors
Journals in science databases
About the Journal
MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Arctic and Antarctica
Reference:

Middle and Late Holocene landslides on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge

Slyshkina Elena

Head of the Laboratory of JSC Atomenergoproekt

119234, Russia, g. Moscow, ul. Podol'skikh Kursantov, 1, of. 250

lena.slyshkina@gmail.com
Vasil'chuk Yurii Kirillovich

Doctor of Geology and Mineralogy

Professor, Department of Landscape Geochemistry and Soil Geography, Faculty of Geography, Lomonosov Moscow State University

119234, Russia, g. Moscow, ul. Leninskie Gory, 1, of. 2009

vasilch_geo@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2453-8922.2022.1.29498

Received:

11-04-2019


Published:

05-05-2022


Abstract: When studying landslide processes, researchers pay great attention not only to the geometric dimensions of landslide bodies, displacement mechanisms, geomorphological features and reasons for their activation, but also to the time of their activation. The data obtained by radiocarbon dating of organic material selected from various geomorphological elements of landslides in the upper reaches of the Mzymta river basin (Western Caucasus) with a large sample of samples allow us to confidently say about the age of the event, or several episodes of landslide formation, the frequency of repetition of the process, as well as to establish the trigger causes that triggered the landslide. To obtain more reliable definitions of the age of the landslide, a method for performing serial selection of organic matter has been developed. Organic material was selected from various elements of the landslide : a) from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide, b) from sections of depressions on the main body of the landslide, c) from the humus horizon buried under the lingual part of the landslide. More than 40 new dates of samples of organic material have been obtained. The chronology of late- and Mid-Holocene landslides in the valley of the Mzymta river has been performed: 1. Landslides located on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge were formed during two major stages of landslide formation; 2. The older stage of landslide formation dates from the Middle Holocene from 6310 to 5380 cal. 3. The relatively younger stage of landslide formation dates from the Middle Holocene from 2930 to 2820 cal. years ago.


Keywords:

holocene, landslides, radiocarbon dating, Aibga Ridge, Mzymta River Valley, Western Caucasus, lake-marsh depressions, Aibginsky fault, trigger reasons for activation, reconstruction of landslide history

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

Introduction

 When studying landslide processes, researchers pay great attention not only to the geometric dimensions of landslide bodies, displacement mechanisms, geomorphological features and reasons for their activation, but also to the time of their activation. The data obtained by radiocarbon dating of organic material selected from various geomorphological elements of landslides with a large sample of samples [1-9] allow us to confidently say about the age of the event, or several episodes of landslide formation, the frequency of repetition of the process, as well as to establish the trigger causes that triggered the landslide.

To establish the history of landslide activity in the Middle and Late Holocene, the authors performed radiocarbon dating of organic material accumulated in lake-marsh drainage basins in the rear part of sliding landslides on the northern slope of the Aibga.

Materials and methods of research. Field work was carried out in the upper reaches of the Mzymta river basin (Western Caucasus), in the central part of the northern slope of the Aibga ridge (Fig. 1), approximately 7.0–11.0 km east of the village. Krasnaya Polyana, on the territory of the Sochi National Park, in the immediate vicinity of the Aibginsky fault. During field research, 4 sliding landslides 17-SS6, 17-SS10, 17-SS11, 17-SS15 were studied, described and tested.

 

 

Fig. 1. Overview map of the study area with the main faults and tested landslides in the valley of the Mzymta river: black circles – the locations of dated landslides and their number; active faults: A – Aibginsky, B – Bekisheysky, Mz – Mzymta, E – Estosadoksky; line with bergstreaks – discharge (bergstreaks are directed towards the omitted wings), discontinuous lines – mainly shifts

            Methods of work. The methodical approach to the dating of landslides is that each landslide is considered as original and its testing is carried out according to an individual scheme. For example, when dating a sliding landslide, material is taken from the rear part of the landslide, landslides are dated by the material from the body of the landslide, and landslides flow through the humus of blocked soils or buried roots. The selection varied when dating sliding landslides, currents, and landslides.

In cases where the age of a landslide is represented by a single sample, radiocarbon dating very approximately reflects the time of the collapse. Dating of landslide events from single samples reduces the degree of confidence in the obtained age due to the possible redeposition of the dated material [10].

Ancient material of different ages may be involved inside the landslide: the youngest dates are closest to the age of the landslide. This is especially true for mountainous areas, where there is a constant transfer of material downhill and its re-deposition, and, consequently, a decrease in confidence in the age obtained from single samples. The similarity of the ages of different independent samples increases confidence in the dating of the landslide [1, 2].

The method of performing serial selection of organic material from different elements of the landslide allows us to obtain more reliable definitions of the age of the landslide. New dating of samples of organic material obtained in different parts of landslides: 1) from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide, 2) from sections of depressions on the main body of the landslide, 3) from the humus horizon buried under the linguistic part of the landslide, allow us to reconstruct with a high degree of reliability the chronology of the development of landslides of different scales and different ages.

Research results and their discussion

 

Table 1. Radiocarbon age of samples of organic material from landslides in the upper reaches of the Mzymta river basin (Western Caucasus), in the central part of the northern slope of the Aibga ridge

n/a

Lab. No.

Sampling depth, m

Material

14With age, years

Calendar age, cal. years

 

Landslide body 17-SS5

Samples from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide

1

LU-8890

0,35

Borozems

590±70

590±40

2

LU-8891

0,50

Borozems

1530±90

1440±90

3

LU-8892

1,05

Borozems

1420±90

1340±90

4

LU-8893

1,60

Borozems

2780±150

2930±190

Sample from the landslide body

5

LU-8894

1,30

Embers of wood

2240±90

2240±120

 

Landslide body 17-SS8

Samples from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide

6

LU-8901

0,25

Borozems

370±80

400±80

7

LU-8902

0,50

Borozems

480±90

500±90

8

LU-8903

0,70

Borozems

980±100

890±110

Sample from the landslide body

9

LU-8904

0,80

Embers of wood

5520±130

6310±150

 

Landslide body 17-SS9

Samples from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide

10

LU-8905

0,25

Borozems

210±80

210±130

11

LU-8907

0,80

Borozems

1330±90

1230±90

12

LU-8908

1,20

Humus

2700±150

2820±200

Landslide body 17-SS13

Samples from sections of depressions in the rear part of the landslide

13

LU-8922

0,25

Borozems

1270±120

1180±120

14

LU-8923

0,45

Borozems

4010±110

4500±170

Sample from the landslide body

15

LU-8924

1,33

Embers of wood

4690±130

5380±170

Note. Calendar age values are given based on the calibration program "OxCal 4.2" (calibration curve "IntCal 13" [10], Christopher Bronk Ramsey [11].

The consequent landslide of shift 17-SS8 is located on a slope with a steepness of 35-40 °, at absolute elevations of 1201-1161 m and have an oval shape in plan. The length of the landslide in the direction of displacement is ~ 225 m, width ~ 210 m, sediment thickness ~ 25-30 m. The total volume of the soil involved in the displacement is 1.8 million m3.

 

 

Fig. 2. Sequential landslide of shift 17-SS8. Yellow shows the body of the landslide

 

The entire delapsive and accumulative part of the landslide is covered with grassy vegetation, undergrowth, aspen and tall century-old oaks. The depressions on the body of the landslide and the lingual part are swampy, fern grows on them. In the sides and the central part, the landslide is opened by temporary watercourses. The presence of normally developing vegetation and the absence of surface deformations and cracks outlining the landslide indicate a phase of temporary stabilization of the landslide process.

The basis of the displacement of the landslide at the time of its formation was the valley of the Mzymta River. The rocks of the main deformable horizon are represented by a lumpy soil with a loamy filler. Blocks of sandstone, limestone, and igneous rocks reach sizes 15-20 m across. The separation niche is technogenically altered and planned, covered with herbaceous and shrubby vegetation, poorly expressed in relief.

In the section of the depression in the rear part of the landslide, organic residues are represented by concentrated wood residues and scattered organic matter – in the form of soil humus. The passed pit in the lake-marsh drainage basin in the rear part of the landslide exposed from top to bottom: 1) brown soils (up to 0.7 m) of dark gray color, with a high content of dispersed organic matter; 2) lumpy soil with a loamy filler of light brown solid consistency (0.7-1.5 m) - landslide deposits. Samples of LU-8901, LU-8902, LU-8903 and at the contact of the borozems and landslide deposits (wood embers – LU-8904) were selected from the borozems.

The block landslide of shift 17-SS9 is localized at absolute elevations of 1591-1553 m, on a slope with a steepness of 45-50 °. It has an oval shape in plan. The length of the landslide body in the direction of displacement is ~160 m, width ~ 105 m, sediment thickness ~ 35 m (Fig. 3). The total volume of the soil involved in the displacement is approximately 0.6 million m3.

 

 

Fig. 3. Block landslide of shift 17-SS9

 

The delapsive part of the landslide is blocked from above by talus deposits in the form of small detrital material and large blocks that have moved from the separation niche to its surface. Huge landslide boulders on the surface of the landslide, covered with a thin soil layer and moss. Young trees grow on the surface of the blocks. The surface of the landslide is overgrown with shrubs, woody vegetation and ferns, the demolition of colluvial material is observed. Many trees are broken by landslide boulders that fall out of the root niche of the separation and are located near the wall on the surface of the landslide (which indicates a single landslide event). The drainless basin in the rear part of the landslide is heavily waterlogged. The breakaway niche is a steep (70-90 °) cliff with a height of ~ 20 m and a width of ~ 130 m, composed of strongly mature, strongly cracked rocks. The age of the landslide event is indicated by the powerful (0.45 m), well-defined horizon of brown soils, as well as the absence of modern stretching cracks and stabs. The phase of the landslide process (to date) is a long–term stabilization.

To determine the age of the landslide, organic residues were selected in the section of the depression in its rear watered part. In the context of the zapadina, the selected organic residues are represented by concentrated wood residues and scattered organic material – in the form of soil humus. The pit passed in the rear part of the landslide body (Fig. 2) exposed from top to bottom: 1) brown soils (up to 0.8 m) of dark gray color, with a high content of scattered organic matter (according to the classification of soils of Russia, 2004); 2) colluvial deposits (0.8–1.2 m); 3) humus horizon buried under colluvial deposits (1.2–1.4 m). Sampling of organic material was carried out from the borozems LU-8905, LU-8907 and the humus horizon LU-8908.

The consequent landslide of shift 17-SS13 is located in the side of the Sulimovsky Creek, a left–bank tributary of the Mzymta River at absolute elevations of 938-910 m. The length of the landslide in the direction of displacement is ~90 m, width ~120 m, sediment thickness ~12-15 m (Fig. 3). The exposed sediment thickness in the tongue of the landslide by the erosion cut is 7.6 m. The total volume of the soil involved in the displacement approximately reaches 160 thousand m3.

 

 

Fig. 4. Sequential landslide of shift 17-SS13

 

The entire delapsive and accumulative part of the landslide is covered with grass vegetation, undergrowth and tall woody vegetation. The thickness of the soil layer on the inclined surface of the body is 0.5 m. The body of the landslide is crossed by two active watercourses with a small flow. The accumulative part of the landslide is flooded. The surface of the landslide is morphologically altered by slope processes, eroded by the drainage system and covered with dense vegetation similar to vegetation on adjacent landscapes. The edge of the breakdown and the delapsive part of the landslide is washed out and is poorly readable in relief. The absence of modern signs of activation of landslide processes, the presence of streams that open the landslide, the accumulated soil layer (0.5 m) on the surface of the landslide indicate a phase of long-term stabilization (to date).

The formation of the 17-CC8 landslide body most likely belongs to the Middle Holocene. This is evidenced by the date 6310 ± 150 cal. years ago (LU-8904). obtained from the coals of wood from a depth of 0.8 m from the upper part of the body of the landslide in contact with the soil from the section of the depression in its rear part. Soil formation in this part of the landslide resumed around 890 cal. years ago, due to an increase in moisture in the rear part of the landslide, probably due to deterioration of drainage and intense precipitation, it lasted up to 370 cal. years ago.

The formation of the 17-SS13 landslide body also belongs to the Middle Holocene. This is evidenced by the date 5380 ±170 cal. years ago (LU-8924). obtained from coals of wood from a depth of 1.33 m from the upper part of the body of the landslide on contact with the soil from the section of the depression in its rear part. However, almost immediately about 4500 cal. years ago, soil formation began here, associated with the formation of an underground swampy reservoir in the rear part of this landslide shortly after the landslide formation.

Active waterlogging is indicated by the bluish color of dated sediments. Then up to 1180 cal. years ago, soil formation took place in more drained conditions, the bluish color of the sediments was replaced by dark brown.

The consequent landslide of shift 17-SS5 is located on a slope with a steepness of 30-35 °, at absolute elevations of 960-901 m and has an oval shape in plan. The length of the landslide body in the direction of displacement is ~ 130 m, width ~ 240 m. The thickness of sediments exposed by the erosion cut-in in the side part of the landslide is 11 m, the estimated thickness in the body of the landslide is 12-15 m. The total volume of the soil involved in the displacement reaches 470 thousand m3.

The delapsive part of the landslide is covered with rare woody vegetation, sometimes having a saber-shaped shape. The thickness of the soil layer on the inclined surface of the landslide body reaches 35-40 cm. In the sides, the landslide is opened by large active streams with predominant bottom erosion. The absence of modern signs of activation of landslide processes, the presence of constantly operating streams that open the landslide in the sides, the accumulated soil layer (0.3-0.40 cm) on the surface of the landslide indicate the phase of its long-term stabilization.

The basis of the displacement of the landslide at the time of its formation and activation was the valley of the Mzymta River. The movement of the language part did not reach the river's edge and presumably stopped in the central part of the slope. Rocks of the main deformable horizon are represented by coarse–grained, poorly rolled, unsorted material with loamy aggregate. The cirque-shaped breakaway niche is a steep (50-55°) cliff ~40 m high and ~250 m wide, covered with a layer of deluvial-talus deposits, sparse woody vegetation and cut by small temporary watercourses. In the south-western part, the separation niche has been technogenically changed, secured with a nagel field and a counter-basement grid, in the south-eastern part technological roads have been cut on its surface, cable networks have been laid, surface drainage has been equipped and an anti-basement grid has been fixed.

To determine the age of the 17-SS5 landslide, organic residues were selected in the section of the depression in the rear part. Organic material is represented by concentrated wood residues and dispersed – in the form of humus of soils. The pit laid in the lake-marsh drainage basin in the rear part of the landslide (Fig. 1) exposed from top to bottom: 1) brown soils (according to the classification of soils of Russia [12]), up to 1.6 m thick, dark gray, brown in color, rich in humus, with the inclusion of colluvial material; 2) landslide deposits - brown loam, semi–solid consistency, with a large number of wood embers, an open capacity of 2.0 m. Sampling of organic material was carried out from the first layer (LU-8890, LU-8891, LU-8892, LU-8894) and at the contact of brown soils and landslide deposits (wood embers – LU-8893).

The interpretation of the distribution of radiocarbon dates in the landslide body 17-SS5 is complicated. Most likely, the formation of a landslide occurred about 3 thousand cal. years ago and immediately formed a swampy underground depression in the rear part of the landslide, where the process of soil formation began, as evidenced by the date 2930 cal. years ago at a depth of 1.6 m. And here are the embers of wood dated 2240 cal. years ago, in a dark layer with traces of fire, they indicate arid conditions that arose 700 years after the landslide formation. The resumed process of soil formation here went on continuously up to 590 cal. years ago.

Almost synchronously with the landslide 17-SS5, a landslide body 17-SS9 - 2820 thousand cal was formed. years ago, judging by the dating of humus in the rear depression. At the same time, the process of soil formation here went on continuously up to 210 cal. years ago.

 

Conclusions

1. Landslides located on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge were formed during two major stages of landslide formation.

2. The older stage of landslide formation dates from the Middle Holocene from 6310 to 5380 cal. years ago.

3. The relatively younger stage of landslide formation dates from the Middle Holocene from 2930 to 2820 cal. years ago.

 

References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The reviewed article is devoted to the study of landslides on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge in the upper reaches of the Mzymta River basin in the Western Caucasus. The methodology of the study is based on the generalization of literary sources on the topic of the work, the application of the method of radiocarbon dating of organic material accumulated in lake-marsh drainage basins in the rear part of the sliding landslides on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge. The relevance of the study is due to the fact that the dating of landslides is of interest for assessing the likelihood of danger, estimating the age of a landslide allows you to correlate landslide phenomena with certain environmental conditions, tectonic, geomorphological and climatic conditions. The scientific novelty of the presented study, according to the reviewer, lies in the obtained results of dating landslides on the northern slope of the Aibga ridge. The following sections are structurally highlighted in the article: Introduction, Materials and methods of research, Methods of work, Research results and their discussion, Conclusions, Bibliography. The introduction reflects the importance of using radiocarbon dating to establish the history of landslide activity in the Middle and Late Holocene. The next section of the article describes the field research area, provides an overview map of the research area with major faults and tested landslides. Then the methodological approach applied by the authors to the dating of landslides is described, according to which each landslide is considered as original and its testing is carried out according to an individual scheme. In the section devoted to the results of the study, the characteristics of samples of organic material from landslides are given: the depth of sampling, the description of the material, the age of the material, the values of the calendar age are given based on the calibration program "OxCal 4.2". The authors considered in detail the Sequential landslide shift, 17-CC8, Block landslide shift 17-CC9, Sequential landslide shift 17-SS13 and the Consequent landslide of shift 17-SS5. The conclusions of the article reflect the three most important results of the conducted research on two major stages of landslide formation and the dating of each of them. The bibliographic list includes 12 names of sources represented by scientific articles by domestic and foreign authors, to which the text contains address links indicating the presence of an appeal to opponents in the publication. According to the reviewed material, one can express a wish: since the article is intended for publication in the journal "Arctic and Antarctica", and the object of research is located in the Western Caucasus, it seems necessary to note in the text of the publication the expediency of publishing the manuscript in this edition in order to pre-empt possible questions from a wide readership, many representatives of which have not been to the Arctic and Antarctic, but we have visited the southern resorts of our country, having justified the correspondence of the topic of the article to the direction of the magazine, the material is recommended for publication after revision in accordance with the comment made.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.