Статья 'Психолого-педагогические аспекты проблемы супервизорской практики в МВД России ' - журнал 'Современное образование' - NotaBene.ru
Journal Menu
> Issues > Rubrics > About journal > Authors > About the Journal > Requirements for publication > Editorial collegium > Editorial board > Peer-review process > Policy of publication. Aims & Scope. > Article retraction > Ethics > Online First Pre-Publication > Copyright & Licensing Policy > Digital archiving policy > Open Access Policy > Article Processing Charge > Article Identification Policy > Plagiarism check policy
Journals in science databases
About the Journal

MAIN PAGE > Back to contents
Modern Education
Reference:

Psychological and pedagogical aspects of the problem of supervisory practice in the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

Zolotova Irina Vladimirovna

teacher, Department of Psychological, Pedagogical and Medical Support of the Department of Internal Affairs, FGOU DPO "All-Russian Institute for Advanced Training of Employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia"

142007, Russia, Domodedovo, Fir street, 3

i.zolotova00@mail.ru

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8736.2023.1.43544

EDN:

XGEPHL

Received:

09-07-2023


Published:

28-08-2023


Abstract: The author in his work examines the issues of the organization of supervision from the point of view of its theoretical and practical significance for various industries and professional communities. In the course of studying this topic, an analysis of available research, conclusions of specialists based on experience and scientific achievements is carried out. The key aspects of the effectiveness of interaction between the supervisor and the supervisor during the implementation of functions, forms, approaches and methods, the purpose of which is to obtain professional skills, knowledge and skills that, after being transferred from the supervisor, will be able to be effectively applied in everyday work by specialists working in the field of assistance and support to citizens and other categories.   The main conclusions of the study are the author's proposals for improving and introducing the experience of supervisors into the practice of law enforcement agencies, from the point of view of improving the quality of education, acquiring significant professional competencies through supervisory practice, which in turn allow solving complex complex tasks in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. The formats of improving the effectiveness of supervisory work in the internal affairs bodies of the Russian Federation are proposed, based on the analysis, practical pedagogical experience accumulated by the author over many years of work. The author highlights the key factors of the supervision process, which from a pedagogical point of view are priority and deserve the attention of specialists in this field.


Keywords:

supervisor, psychologist, specialist, education, system, quality, training, pedagogy, professionalism, organization of preparation

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

From an early age, a person acquires certain skills in various areas of life and does this, as a rule, based on the wishes and requirements of his parents, close relatives who are directly involved in his upbringing and training. Further, moving up the age ladder, his horizons expand and already to the development and formation of him as a person, and in the future as a specialist and professional, various pedagogical structures are connected, which carry out serious work with him, in accordance with the educational standards approved in the state and the requirements for the level of education in a broad sense.

Having approached the threshold of obtaining a citizen, in accordance with constitutional norms, compulsory basic general education, many people have a question of their further development and formation in accordance with their level of intelligence, creative abilities, skills and predisposition to a particular activity. Based on these circumstances, people choose various directions in which they continue their development and formation, hone their skills, increase their level of competence, etc. In the pedagogical sense, it is a great success if a young specialist is accompanied for a sufficient time by a professional colleague, mentor, who will be able to transfer his experienced knowledge and share practical and theoretical aspects of professional activity.

In my work, I would like to consider topical issues of supervision, supervisory practice in the field of organizing and conducting such work in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, due to the fact that this area of work is important and necessary for many objective reasons.

Undoubtedly, many research papers of such authors as Smirnova S.V., Martinson K.E., Mikhailova S.E., Gotsiridze A., Mukhametkulova V.I., Varga A.Ya., Galasyuk I.N., Mitina O.V., Kotova S.A. and others are devoted to supervision issues. Scientists have considered a large number of problematic topics, such as the professional training of supervisors, their role in group supervision, levels and models of interaction, opportunities when working with a supervisor supervisor, as an effective tool for studying, analyzing and resolving complex situations in the practice of psychologists.

In our opinion, based on the accumulated experience and practical skills of many years of work as a psychologist, the implementation of teaching activities, when in the course of training you receive feedback from students with various psychological work experience, evaluate the information received, arguments and problems, we can conclude that supervisory practice in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia should develop and improve.

In her work, Yakimanskaya I.S. considers a supervisor as a psychologist with special training, qualification in the direction of "supervisory activity". In turn, psychological supervision is presented by her as one of the methods of professional development in the field of psychological counseling, where one psychologist helps another in identifying problem points, resolving difficulties, and professional development [1]. This is a point of view that we share with the author and believe that it is effective when conducting supervisory work with psychologists of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. In this creative, trusting work, it is very important to observe the basics of professional ethics of supervisors.

For several decades, supervision has been a targeted pedagogical product, providing clinical practice, professional development of a specialist, in a meaningful and qualitative aspect, anticipating and minimizing possible errors, the application of which is focused on those areas and professions in the center of which is a person. 

Based on world experience, there is a practice when a supervisor plays an important role in the formation of a psychologist's professionalism. And in this regard, of course, it is very important to note the motivation to undergo supervision on the part of various categories of specialists of the internal affairs bodies of the Russian Federation.

In general, supervision is a systematic format of work for specialists of helping professions. The role of the supervisor is not only to provide specific assistance, but also the ability to share responsibility for the decision made together with a less experienced specialist. Supervision is an effective and dynamic tool for finding new opportunities, gaining knowledge and acquiring the necessary experience, as well as comprehensive professional support.

Certain requirements are also applied to supervisors, which should be the rules in the organization of this work, namely:

• good level of work organization;

• competence;

• responsibility;

• confidentiality;

         And as Rettikh A.A. rightly notes in his work, during supervision, a specialist should monitor the dynamics of professional development of a psychologist receiving supervision [2].

         According to Varg A.Ya., Galasyuk I.N., Mitina O.V., the supervisor, assessing his expectations from supervision, identifies three components:

1. knowledge;

2. building a professional identity;

3. the focus of the work [3].

The researchers also noted that supervisors distinguish several important factors from the supervision process, which, in our opinion, is noteworthy from a pedagogical point of view:

- training,

- understanding;

- support;

- ethics;

- novelty.

Projecting these factors onto the pedagogical process carried out at the Department of Psychological, Pedagogical and Medical Support of the Department of Internal Affairs of FGKU DPO VIPK of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, during which students undergo advanced training, we note that these are classic components of the system of additional professional education, the purpose of which is to acquire new competencies based on the principles of humanism and democracy.

In our opinion, one of the examples of the implementation of the functions of supervisors can be considered the work of a teacher-curator on the organization of industrial practice of students undergoing professional training under the polygraph examiner training program for the internal affairs bodies of the Russian Federation, where all the functionality of interaction aimed at obtaining quality education takes place.

This should be done in order to assess the effectiveness of the professional training program for polygraph examiners, the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia conducts various methods of research and evaluation of learning outcomes. One of the most effective methods is the assessment of practical skills and abilities of polygraph examiners after completion of the training process [4].

Noteworthy is the definition of supervision as purposeful, organized advisory and educational support that an individual, group or organization receives in a professional context in order to improve professional competence and improve the quality of professional activity [5].

If the basis of supervisory practice in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia is based on the accumulated positive experience of this work from various sources, taking into account such basic functions of supervision as educational, support, management, control and evaluation, then in our opinion it is possible to put forward an assumption about the preparation of training programs for supervisors in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, in the format of a pilot project and to introduce the obtained experimental result into departmental practical bodies, organizations and divisions. 

References
1. Yakimanskaya, I. S., Biktina, N. N. (2015). Psychological counseling. Orenburg: Orenburg State University.
2. Rettikh, A. A. (2022). Professional ethics of psychological supervisors. MODERN SCIENCE: CURRENT ISSUES, ACHIEVEMENTS and INNOVATIONS : collection of articles of the XXIII International Scientific and Practical Conference, pp. 238-240. Penza: Science and Education.
3. Varga, A. Ya. A., Galasyuk, I.N., & Mitina, O. V. (2022). Representations of supervisors and supervisors about professional supervision. Clinical and special psychology, 1(11), 120-140. doi:10.17759/cpse.2022110106
4. Sadekov, R.R. (2023) Strategy of special professional training of polygraph examiners in the system of departmental education of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. Policing, 2, 64-72. doi:10.7256/2454-0692.2023.2.40095
5. Martinson, K. E.,  Mikhailova, S. E., Mikhailov,  & I. Ya. P. (2014). Supervisor competence and development of supervisor education in the Republic of Latvia. Psychology of education in the multicultural space, 1(25), 5-10.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The object of research in the manuscript submitted for review is supervisory practice as a pedagogical phenomenon. The subject is its implementation in educational institutions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. The work is completely theoretical in nature, and the main research method is descriptive and narrative analysis, which is the minimum and generally sufficient level for scientific publication in the format of a journal article. A detailed review of the studies of the designated problem, indicating specific authors and vectors of scientific work in this problem field, deserves attention. The work is written in a language generally consistent with the norms of scientific style. Individual deviations will be indicated below. There are a number of comments on the submitted text. The volume of text without metadata is less than 8000 printed characters, that is, it falls short even to 0.2 printed pages, despite the fact that humanitarian articles of the journal genre traditionally contain at least 15,000-20,000 printed characters (about 0.5 pp.l.) The article is not divided into theoretical and practical parts, which is traditional for psychological and pedagogical research. Even in purely theoretical works, conclusions and reflections are expected that "bridge the gap" to practice. It is better to remove the word "problem" from the title, because the author writes about supervisory practice as an accepted phenomenon, without subjecting it to any criticism. It is better to call the article "The main aspects of supervisory practice ..." If the word aspects exists in the title, it is expected to list specific aspects and group them, for example, pedagogical, psychological, organizational. In general, this information is present in the text, however, the meaningful grouping has not been performed. The following paragraph does not meet the requirements of scientific style. "In my work, I would like to consider topical issues of supervision, supervisory practice in the field of organizing and conducting such work in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, due to the fact that this area of work is important and necessary for many objective reasons" Instead of "I" should write "we", the wording "would like" is unacceptable. In general, impersonal formulations are welcome in the scientific text "the work considers ... etc." The relevance of the work is presented in a popular educational, but not in a scientific style. From the first paragraphs, it is not possible to conclude why the topic is important for science and practice. It is necessary to clarify the correspondence of the authors in the research review and in the list of references. The conclusions are formulated too generally. "If the basis of supervisory practice in the system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia is based on the existing accumulated positive experience of this work from various sources, ....." It would be desirable to provide information on recommended experience at the level of specific methods, forms, means and pedagogical actions. Conclusion: the text has the format of abstracts for the conference, that is, a brief "threshold" review, in which the actual problem is addressed, but not disclosed in scientific and analytical terms. Taking into account the high relevance and thematic relevance, this manuscript may be published in the journal of pedagogical Sciences at the discretion of the editorial board.
Link to this article

You can simply select and copy link from below text field.


Other our sites:
Official Website of NOTA BENE / Aurora Group s.r.o.